Socrates and Dionysus: Philosophy and Art in Dialogue

Socrates and Dionysus engages and seeks to redraw the bounds among philosophy and poetry, technological know-how and paintings. Friedrich Nietzsche argues in his paintings The start of Tragedy that technological know-how conquers paintings, particularly the tragic paintings of the Dionysian poet of historic Greece. attractive to the normal, primeval self that's suppressed yet now not extinguished through the information of tradition, Dionysian tragedy establishes touch with bodies and their inner most longings. technology and philosophy, linked to the ‘Socratism’ of the theoretical guy, have fun the human brain particularly and the brain or rationality of the universe extra generally.

According to Nietzsche, it really is Euripides who destroys the Dionysian completely. Euripides celebrated the unadorned person simply because in basic terms the person, separated from their god, is intelligible or available to human cause; he insisted that artwork be comprehended through brain or that it's rationally understood. Euripides used to be possessed of this kind of rationalizing force, Nietzsche claims, simply because his basic viewers used to be Socrates. it really is Socrates, hence, who's the real opponent of Dionysus. Following Nietzsche’s bifurcation among philosophy and paintings, postmodern political thinker Richard Rorty rejects the tendency of philosophy to posit absolute, common truths and turns to the idea that of ‘redescription’ which he affiliates with the ‘wisdom of the novel’. the radical is sensible since it posits the relative truths and views of a number of the members, societies and cultures that it represents. As an paintings shape, it may well for that reason contain each attainable point of view of each specific scenario, occasion or person.

New interdisciplinary fields in politics, literature and movie are giving upward push to an increasing group of students who disagree with the techniques taken by way of Nietzsche and Rorty. those students are laying off mild at the ways that philosophy and artwork are pals instead of enemies. They search to bridge the theoretical and moral gaps among the realm of ‘fiction’ and the realm of ‘fact’, of artwork and technology. There seems to be a primary rigidity among literary-artistic and medical initiatives. while the artist seeks to recreate human event, thereby evoking simple moral matters, the scientist it appears seeks ethically-neutral, evidence-based evidence because the parts of our wisdom of truth. Chapters during this quantity, notwithstanding, will re-evaluate how artists, philosophers and film-makers have addressed and tried to reconcile the artist’s language of normativity and the scientist’s language of facticity.

Show description

Read Online or Download Socrates and Dionysus: Philosophy and Art in Dialogue PDF

Similar art books

Philosophy and Conceptual Art

The analytic philosophers writing the following interact with the cluster of philosophical questions raised by way of conceptual artwork. They deal with 4 large questions: what sort of paintings is conceptual artwork? What follows from the truth that conceptual paintings doesn't goal to have aesthetic worth? What wisdom or realizing will we achieve from conceptual paintings?

Making Prints from Nature (Storey's Country Wisdom Bulletin A-177)

When you consider that 1973, Storey's state knowledge announcements have provided functional, hands-on directions designed to assist readers grasp dozens of kingdom dwelling talents fast and simply. There are actually greater than a hundred and seventy titles during this sequence, and their striking recognition displays the typical hope of nation and town dwellers alike to domesticate own independence in daily life.

At Large: Ai Weiwei on Alcatraz

Across the world popular chinese language artist and activist Ai Weiwei is certainly one of modern art's such a lot newsworthy figures, famous for either his groundbreaking paintings and his outspoken stance on human rights, which eventually ended in his debatable 2011 detainment. In an staggering new large-scale venture, he turns his awareness to Alcatraz—a position he can't stopover at simply because he isn't approved to depart China, yet that stands as a world-famous image of either incarceration and protest.

The Total Film Maker

‘The overall Film-Maker’ — Jerry Lewis’ booklet on filmmaking, taken from 480 hours of audio tape, recorded as Jerry taught filmmaking on the college of Southern California, 1971. “It’s it appears the best books written approximately filmmaking ever. It used to be revealed in 1971 and has been out of print due to the fact then.

Extra resources for Socrates and Dionysus: Philosophy and Art in Dialogue

Sample text

Though they would correct the naïve hopefulness of the Melians, it is the hope of the Athenians for a world that recognizes and rewards their superior goodness, a hope no less naïve than that of the Melians, that needs correcting. The Melian dialogue, by revealing the incoherence of the Athenians’ efforts, suggests that any attempt by purely human means to disclose openly and candidly the link between superior moral goodness and superior power requires a less direct route, a less candid route, a less explicit route, one that cannot be captured in speeches and certainly not captured in treaties.

Creusa reveals her intention to consult a secret oracle on behalf of a “friend” who was raped by Apollo. Ion defends the god, but she departs when Xuthus’ arrival prevents her from asking “what the god is not willing [to speak]” (Euripides 1999, 375-80, also 810-20, 1055-60). Xuthus consults the Oracle and reappears with the message that his son will be the first person he sees upon exiting the temple; this person is Ion. Ion resists Xuthus’ interpretation of the Oracle and notes that, as the bastard son of a foreigner, he will be rejected by the Athenians.

But at the end of the History the rule of such “violence” is replaced by a measured regime that joins together contentious parts of the city without privileging one part over the others. , religious) sources of law and order. Given that The Five Thousand proved remarkably unstable, devolving into full-blown democracy not long after it was established, it is unlikely that Thucydides presents it as an example for other communities to follow. And yet his praise of this regime suggests that we are to take seriously its chief virtue and the encounter with necessity of which it is the product.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.85 of 5 – based on 49 votes